Written By Rick
Ellis, Monday, November 28th, 2004
When HBO's "Six Feet Under" returns in 2005, it won't just be
the end of a long-running hit series. It may also be a turning point for
TV viewers who are in the habit of recording shows to watch weeks or even
months later.
Sources at two different cable companies have told AllYourTV.com that
discussions have begun which will may lead to a restriction of use for
fans of several popular television shows.
The discussions are reportedly in very early stages, and the details are
still very broad. But this is what I can confirm at this date.
A middle-level executive at Time Warner has approached several cable companies
and broached the idea of restricting the ability of customers who use
those company's Digital Video Recorders to record several popular Time
Warner TV programs.
The term being used by the executive is"transitional fair use,"
and the scenerio laid out goes roughly along these lines:
Viewers would be able to record an episode with their DVR, but there would
be a time limit on how long it would be available for viewing. The executive
was pushing for an expiration date that coincided with the premiere of
the next episode. The consensus of the cable executived was that it needed
to be between 2-4 weeks.
Regardless, the episode would then be unavailable until they are offered
as part of a "video on demand" package. There would also be
restrictions on recording episodes via VOD, with the Time Warner executive
pushing for the ability to completely prevent recording the VOD presentations.
Cable executives argue that this restriction prevents time-shifting and
limits the revenue upside for both parties.
Once again, the episodes would be unavailable until they were offered
again on cable, at a date that closely matched the release of the DVD
box set.
While I have been unable to get any of the parties to publicly comment
on the talks, several sources have confirmed the informal talks. It's
difficult to know how serious the discussions will be, but it is known
that several studios have been eyeing a restriction on the ability of
viewers to record video-on-demand and pay-per-view titles.
There is certainly no legal reason to prevent studios or networks from
pursuing this 'transitional copyright' approach to TV viewing. But it's
difficuult for me to see just how it serves the needs of the viewer or
the producers. It seems to be a punitive approach to the problem of illegal
file-sharing. And it seems doomed to failure in the long term. |